What's the Best Barracuda Essentials Alternative?

What is Barracuda Essentials?

Barracuda Essentials for Email is a cloud-based email security solution designed to protect organizations from threats such as phishing, spam, malware, and data loss. It acts as a secure email gateway that filters inbound and outbound email traffic before it reaches users.

What Barracuda Essentials Includes:

• Email Security: Protection against spam, phishing, malware, ransomware, and zero-day threats.
• Advanced Threat Protection (ATP): Sandboxing to detect unknown or emerging threats.
• Email Continuity: Keeps email flowing during server outages or downtime.
• Email Archiving: Long-term, searchable email storage to help with compliance and eDiscovery.
• Data Protection & Backup: Cloud-based backup for Microsoft 365 (Exchange, OneDrive, SharePoint, Teams).

Barracuda Essentials is packaged as an ‘all-in-one’ solution providing:

• Email continuity
• Encryption
• Data leakage protection
• Archiving

The Barracuda spam filter is delivered as Software-as-a-Service (SaaS) , i.e., no hardware or local software installs are required.

Pros and Cons of Barracuda Essentials

Every email filter solution has positives and negatives in its application, deployment, and use. The key to making the right choice is to know what these are and to balance them with the specific needs of your organization.

Barracuda Essentials pros and cons include:

Pros:

• Comprehensive security portfolio covering major threat vectors
• Real-time threat detection to ensure 24/7/365 protection
• Uses over 170,000 active sites to provide threat intelligence
• Uses a layered approach to email protection applying behavioral, heuristic, and sandboxing technologies and offers AI-enabled detection
• Protect against zero-hour, targeted, and ransomware attacks
• Outbound and inbound email protection
• A cloud-based failover service acts to ensure email continuity during web server outages, etc.
• Integrated with Office365
• Strong brand recognition and market presence

Cons:

A review of the user ratings of Barracuda Essentials reveals a few areas of the product that could be improved:

• Massive year-over-year price increases frustrate customers
• Awareness training requires add-ons/upsells, not included
• Heavy setup and management requirements strain IT resources
• Speed issues of the portal and email archiving function have been noted
• Lack of granularity of features such as always-on email encryption
• Packaging is more complex for MSPs than MSP-first alternatives
• Less cost-effective than other solutions such as SpamTitan
• Poor support of product

Barracuda Essentials is designed for larger organizations, and therefore, can be more complex to set up and configure. Barracuda, in line with its enterprise design, provides for more complex routing scenarios and granular content filtering policies.

SpamTitan is a market leader in catching spam with a 99.9% Catch Rate.

Barracuda Alternatives

When choosing a solution to provide your organization with robust, holistic email protection, it is vital to analyze the alternatives.

The deployment and configuration of company-wide solutions, such as email protection, is potentially a long-term commitment, so picking the best product for your circumstances is essential.

Some Barracuda alternatives are:

Mimecast Secure Email Gateway

Mimecast has a portfolio of security products, including an email security gateway. The solution is designed for larger enterprises, although it could be used by an SMB.

The Mimecast Secure Email Gateway provides:

• Protection for all cloud or perimeter-based inbound emails
• Delivery of email protection is cloud-based
• Real-time threat analysis is performed
• The email protection prevents attacks via malware, phishing, and other web-borne threats
• Mimecast offers outbound email protection via data loss prevention (DLP) to stop sensitive data from leaving an organization
• The service also offers DMARC-compliant brand protection to help stop attacks that are based on a spoof URL made to look like the company owns it

Mimecast, as compared to Barracuda Essentials, does not offer the following:

• Cloud-to-cloud email backup
• AI-enabled email protection
• Limited email detection, analytics and response

Proofpoint Essentials

Proofpoint Essentials is an email security gateway designed for the SMB with a variety of pricing points that reflect the functionality on offer. Email protection uses a full range of features including prevention of phishing and attachment scanning to prevent malware infection.

Other features of Proofpoint Essentials include:

• URL spoof protection
• Policy-driven DLP
• Automated email encryption
• Per-user controls and quarantine access for emergencies and email continuity

Proofpoint Essentials, as compared to Barracuda Essentials:

• Pricing is more SMB friendly
• AI-enabled email protection (dependent on which pricing package is chosen)

SpamTitan

SpamTitan is a leading provider of email security designed for enterprises of all sizes and can be delivered by an MSP. The cloud-based solution provides a holistic, multi-layered approach to web-borne threat prevention.

The solution's design remit is to provide the most advanced threat prevention through AI-enabled detection, coupled with ease of use. SpamTitan is a market leader in catching spam with a 99.9% Catch Rate.

Features of SpamTitan include:

• Easy deployment and configuration
• Automatic updates, pushed out to end-user devices
• Inbound and outbound email protection
• Easy to administer using a central web console
• Supports existing identity systems and robust authentication
• No hardware or endpoint software needed, fully cloud-based
• Collaborative spam fingerprint checks based on “community intelligence“ from over 650 million users
• Advanced threat detection using AI
• Multi-layered email protection to prevent modern threats
• DMARC email authentication

SpamTitan, compared to Barracuda Essentials:

• Pricing of SpamTitan is more affordable than Barracuda
• MSP-first model, 70-80% MSP customer base
• Deploy in under 30 minutes, clean, simple UX.
• Transparent pricing from $3.74/user/month, tiered models for margin growth
• Someone always picks up the phone, a dedicated Account Manager.
• White-label, multi-tenant, MSP-first architecture
• Low management overhead, automated workflows
• Barracuda does not support DMARC email authentication

The Best Option: SpamTitan

The choice between Barracuda and SpamTitan reflects a decision between complexity and simplicity, between escalating costs and predictable pricing, between deteriorating support and personal relationships.

Choose Barracuda only if your organization absolutely requires their specific firewall or web application security capabilities and has the resources to manage the platform's notorious complexity. 

Be prepared for massive year-over-year price increases, the challenge of their EOL strategy forcing you into expensive bundles, and support experiences that many customers describe as frustrating. Organizations with large, dedicated security teams capable of handling heavy setup and management requirements might find value. Still, they should budget for significant cost escalation and consider the high export fees that make leaving difficult.

Choose SpamTitan when you want a security platform that's actually easy to work with,  one that provides all the familiar features you expect from Barracuda, plus innovative capabilities.

For MSPs, the choice is even clearer: TitanHQ's MSP-first model with one contract, one support path, and one Account Manager eliminates the complexity that makes Barracuda challenging for multi-tenant environments. With deployment in under 30 minutes, transparent pricing starting at $3.74 per user per month, and someone who always picks up the phone when you call, TitanHQ delivers enterprise-grade protection without the overhead and pricing of an enterprise-grade solution.

Get Started Here

Kaizen IT - Migrate from Barracuda to TitanHQ

Sign up for SpamTitan Now!